This website will offer limited functionality in this browser. We only support the recent versions of major browsers like Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge.

Search the website
Thought Leadership

Disclosure – extensions of time and unless orders

Picture of Stacie Bourton
Passle image

The case of Bourlakova v Bourlakov [2026] 10 WLUK 403 highlights what can happen when a party needs more time to give disclosure and the court's approach to considering strike-out and unless orders. 

What happened

This High Court case concerns the alleged misappropriation of assets, a claim now running into billions of dollars. The seventh and eighth defendants, “the Kazakovs”, applied for more time to complete disclosure. The deadline had already been moved from 23 July to 5 October 2026.

The Kazakovs failed to explain the reason for the delay until the claimants applied for a ‘full and frank explanation’. It was then revealed that the Kazakovs’ e-discovery provider had blocked access to their disclosure platform due to unpaid invoices. 

The claimants sought dismissal of the application and the striking out of the Kazakovs’ defences and counterclaims. Failing this, the claimants asked the Court to impose an “unless order”, that is, an automatic penalty for non-compliance by a specified time. 

Relevant principles 

When an extension is sought before a deadline expires, the courts should not refuse a reasonable extension that does not disrupt the case or threaten hearing dates. The applicant must still show that the extension serves a sensible case management purpose. Strike-out is reserved for exceptional cases, such as a deliberate refusal to give disclosure or where a fair trial has become impossible.

The Court's findings

The Kazakovs apologised for the delay, but the judge was particularly troubled by their lack of candour. He found that there was no good reason for the lack of explanation. They had known since 30 June that access to the disclosure platform had been cut off, and their hope of securing funding did not relieve them of their responsibility to provide the Court with an answer. Had they been open, the Court could have intervened sooner and regularised the position. Instead, the parties agreed successive extensions while little disclosure work appeared to have been done until September. With no meaningful evidence of any work between January and June, the judge agreed that the suspension of access was something of a “red herring”. 

Even so, the judge accepted that the extension could "just about" be accommodated within the timetable to trial. He therefore granted a limited extension and refused to strike out the Kazakovs’ case. However, with no remaining flexibility in the timetable, he imposed strict "unless" terms. If the Kazakovs missed any of the deadlines, their defences and counterclaims would be struck out automatically. The judge also warned all parties not to expect similar leniency during the evidential phase.

Key takeaways 

  • The importance of timely explanations. Withholding the reason for a delay damages credibility and removes the chance of timely intervention by the court. 
  • Apply for an extension before the deadline passes. The application was made before the deadline expired. That made an extension easier to obtain than relief after a breach, where the stricter Denton test would be engaged. 
  • Funding difficulties are no automatic shield. Cash-flow difficulties will not excuse a party’s delay if they are not supported by meaningful evidence, particularly where little was done to progress disclosure beforehand.

For more information about the law, technology and practice of disclosure, contact Tom Whittaker or Stacie Bourton.

See more from Burges Salmon

Want more Burges Salmon content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for content and news you can trust.

Update your preferred sources

Follow us on LinkedIn

Be sure to follow us on LinkedIn and stay up to date with all the latest from Burges Salmon.

Follow us