This website will offer limited functionality in this browser. We only support the recent versions of major browsers like Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge.

Search the website
Thought Leadership

Information gaps, foreign forums and director-held documents: pre-action disclosure in El Debs v Coughlan

Picture of Tom Whittaker
Passle image

Pre-action disclosure is an unusual remedy. But where there is a genuine information imbalance, the court has discretion to order early disclosure if it would help resolve the anticipated proceedings fairly, avoid litigation altogether or save costs.

In El Debs v Coughlan [2026] EWHC 2160 (Ch), the High Court ordered pre-action disclosure in connection with potential fraudulent misrepresentation and unlawful means conspiracy claims arising from investments of almost USD6 million. The decision provides useful guidance on the application of CPR 31.16, which is retained for Business and Property Courts proceedings by paragraph 1.8 of PD57AD.

Background to this case

The applicants invested just under USD6 million in Drecford Holdings Limited, an Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) incorporated company. The investment had been promoted by their advisers as safe and low risk, but their investment was ultimately lost. The applicants alleged that their advisers had failed to disclose their principals' interests in Drecford and sought disclosure from the respondent, a director and 50% shareholder of Drecford, to investigate and particularise potential claims for fraudulent misrepresentation and unlawful means conspiracy.

What does pre-action disclosure require?

Under CPR 31.16(3), the court may order pre-action disclosure only where the respondent is likely to be a party to subsequent proceedings; the applicant is also likely to be a party to those proceedings; any pre-action disclosure is likely to be in scope of future disclosure requirements; and it is desirable to order pre-action disclosure.

Even where those requirements are satisfied, the court retains discretion whether to make an order, having regard to all the circumstances.

Below, we highlight some practical takeaways from the decision:

You can seek disclosure before deciding whether to bring a claim

An applicant does not need to show that proceedings are likely to be issued. The question is whether the applicant and respondent would be likely to be parties if proceedings were brought (see Black v Sumitomo Corp [2001] EWCA Civ 1819). This can be particularly important where the documents being sought may help establish whether there is a viable claim in the first place. Here, the applicants could seek documents to understand and properly formulate their potential claims without first showing that litigation would probably follow (paragraphs 28–32 and 50).

Early disclosure can help fill important information gaps

Meeting the requirements of CPR 31.16 does not guarantee disclosure. The court retains a discretion and will consider what early disclosure could achieve. Here, the respondent was in a position to explain how the applicants' investment of almost USD6 million had been lost, but had not done so. Disclosure could therefore help the applicants properly formulate their claims and avoid costly later amendments. Equally, the documents might provide an innocent explanation and avoid proceedings altogether (paragraphs 73–77).

A possible dispute over where the claim should be heard is not necessarily a barrier

The respondent argued that the claims should naturally be heard in the ADGM rather than England. However, the applicants did not need to establish, at the pre-action disclosure stage, that proceedings were likely to be brought in England or that any future claim would survive a challenge over the appropriate forum (see Black v Sumitomo Corp [2001] EWCA Civ 181 and Pineway Ltd v London Mining Co Ltd [2010] EWHC 1143 (Comm)). Those issues could still be relevant to the court's overall discretion, but they did not prevent the court from ordering disclosure here (paragraph 50).

Company documents can still be relevant when disclosure is sought from a director

The respondent argued that much of the material belonged to the companies and was therefore not within his control. The respondent relied on Lonrho Ltd v Shell Petroleum Co Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 627 and Three Rivers DC v Bank of England (No 4) [2003] 1 WLR 210 for the proposition that even a controlling shareholding does not of itself give a person control of a company’s documents; control requires a presently enforceable legal right to obtain them.

But the court distinguished Lonrho as it concerned whether a parent company controlled its subsidiary company’s documents; the position differs where documents are held by a director in their capacity as a director. As stated in B v B (Matrimonial Proceedings: Discovery) [1978] Fam 181 at 187G: "How do these general principles apply to the director of a company in relation to company documents, that is, to documents which are in the possession of the company in the sense that the company has the sole legal right to their possession. If they are or have been in the custody or physical possession of the director, even if he only held them or holds them as servant or agent of the company, or in his capacity as an officer of the company, then they must be disclosed. Whether such documents are or have been in his custody is a question of fact in each case." Here, the respondent was "clearly the controlling mind" of Drecford and the court inferred that he held its documents as a director (paragraphs 70–71).

Key Takeaways:

  • You do not have to commit to proceedings before seeking disclosure. Pre-action disclosure can help establish whether there is a viable claim and how it should be pleaded
  • Pre-action disclosure can help fill genuine information gaps. The court may order early disclosure where it could help clarify or properly plead a claim, avoid unnecessary proceedings, or save the costs of later amendments.
  • Company documents may be disclosable by an individual director. Although being a shareholder does not itself give someone control of company documents, documents held by a director in that capacity may fall within their custody or possession and therefore be subject to disclosure.

For more information about the law, technology and practice of disclosure, contact Tom Whittaker or Stacie Bourton.

See more from Burges Salmon

Want more Burges Salmon content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for content and news you can trust.

Update your preferred sources

Follow us on LinkedIn

Be sure to follow us on LinkedIn and stay up to date with all the latest from Burges Salmon.

Follow us