This website will offer limited functionality in this browser. We only support the recent versions of major browsers like Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge.

Search the website
Thought Leadership

Before you hit record: the ICO’s reminder on workplace monitoring

Picture of Ellen Goodland
Passle image

This article has been co-authored with Emma Woods, Senior Apprentice Solicitor. 

The Information Commissioner (ICO) has recently commented on the use of audio recordings, and it's a useful reminder that introducing new monitoring measures isn't just a technology decision. It's a data protection one too. This is particularly relevant for employers, who may use audio recordings in a range of workplace contexts, for example to create an accurate record of discussions during meetings.

The ICO's comments followed an investigation into a school which, after a safeguarding incident, took the decision to expand its CCTV system to include audio recording in specialist support rooms. While the school's intention was to protect both pupils and staff, the ICO identified a key issue with what the school had done: namely to introduce this new method of processing without first carrying out a Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA).

Following the ICO’s investigation and after carrying out a DPIA, the school revised its privacy policy, contacted affected parents directly and put up signs explaining that audio recording was in use. It is an important reminder for employers that before introducing new ways of collecting personal data, organisations need to stop and consider the impact on individuals' privacy rights.

For employers, this is particularly relevant as workplace monitoring practices continue to evolve. Whether it's software that tracks employee activity, biometric access controls or the recording of workplace conversations, the question is not simply whether the technology can be used, but whether it is necessary, proportionate and properly assessed.

Considerations for employers

1. Define what you are seeking to achieve from the monitoring 

Before selecting or introducing a monitoring tool, employers should consider what it is seeking to monitor in practical terms: is the information genuinely needed, why is it needed and what objective is the monitoring intending to achieve.

Employers should also assess whether the proposed tool is the least intrusive way of meeting that objective. This analysis should then be documented as part of the DPIA.

2. Carry out a DPIA before introducing new surveillance measures

A DPIA is required where processing is likely to result in a high risk to individuals' rights and freedoms. “High risk” in this context means that the proposed processing has the potential to significantly affect individuals’ privacy or other rights and freedoms. In an employment context, this might arise where monitoring is particularly intrusive or extensive, captures sensitive information, or is used to inform decisions which could have a significant impact on an employee. As a matter of good practice, it is generally recommended to carry out a DPIA when introducing any new workplace monitoring. This helps employers assess whether the monitoring is necessary and proportionate, identify and mitigate risks, and consider appropriate safeguards. 

More than a box-ticking exercise, a DPIA helps organisations identify privacy risks early, assess whether those risks can be mitigated, and demonstrates that employee privacy rights have been properly considered before implementation.

3. Be clear on why the monitoring is needed

Employers need a lawful basis for processing personal data. In many workplace monitoring scenarios, this basis is likely to be because the processing is in the employer's legitimate interests. Where the monitoring involves the processing of special category data, employers will also need to identify an appropriate condition for processing that data.

However, relying on ‘legitimate interests’ is not as simple as stating that the monitoring would be useful. Employers must balance their interests with an employee’s fundamental rights and freedoms and be able to explain why the processing is necessary and proportionate, and why less intrusive alternatives would not achieve the same objective.

In the context of audio recording, for example, depending on the nature and circumstances of the recording, there may be a heightened impact on employee privacy, particularly where sensitive information may be captured during conversations. Employers should therefore consider whether the purpose of the recording could be achieved through less intrusive measures before concluding that recording conversations is required.

4. Tell employees what is happening

If your DPIA indicates that audio monitoring can be justified, transparency is key. Employees should understand what information is being collected, why it is being collected and how it will be used. Depending on the nature and extent of the monitoring, employers should also consider how best to engage with the workforce, including any recognised trade union or employee representatives, before the monitoring is introduced. This can help to identify and address concerns at an early stage and ensure employees understand both the purpose of the monitoring and how it will operate in practice.

This information may be included in a privacy notice, a standalone monitoring policy or both. Importantly, what is reflected in the policy and communicated to employees must accurately reflect what happens in practice.

5. Make sure people know when they are being recorded

If audio recording is being used, employees should be given clear information about when recordings may take place and the purpose behind the recording.

Being upfront about recording practices and why the recordings are necessary helps build trust.

The takeaway:

The lesson from the ICO's intervention is straightforward: if you're considering a new form of workplace monitoring, carry out a robust DPIA before implementing the technology and ensure it clearly demonstrates why the monitoring is necessary, proportionate and justified. A well-prepared DPIA not only stress-tests the decision-making process, but also provides a clear record of the rationale for the monitoring, the risks identified and the steps taken to mitigate them.

Need help navigating your data protection issues, DPIA, DSARs or figuring out how to implement these processes in your organisation? Please contact Ellen Goodland, Helen Haworth or your usual Burges Salmon contact.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Related sectors

See more from Burges Salmon

Want more Burges Salmon content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for content and news you can trust.

Update your preferred sources

Follow us on LinkedIn

Be sure to follow us on LinkedIn and stay up to date with all the latest from Burges Salmon.

Follow us