This website will offer limited functionality in this browser. We only support the recent versions of major browsers like Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge.

Search the website
Thought Leadership

The return of “proper pensions”? Government consults on guided retirement framework

Picture of Louise Pettit
Passle image

On 3 November, the DWP, the Pensions Regulator (TPR) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) launched a joint consultation on proposals for implementing new guided retirement requirements for DC schemes. Badged by the Pensions Minister as the “return of proper pensions”, and described in the consultation as its “core retirement policy”, guided retirement is a central plank of the Government’s ongoing reform programme, which has at its heart a vision for a future with fewer, bigger, more well-run schemes that provide better outcomes for members.

The consultation paper elaborates on some of the principles outlined in the July 2026 policy paper and sets out the proposed shape of the new guided retirement framework. Running to some 71 questions, industry input is sought on some key tenets of the Government’s vision for guided retirement. Whilst many of the questions focus on the ability of master trusts and contract-based providers to deliver default pensions that meet the new requirements, there are also questions addressed to trust-based schemes more broadly. 

The consultation closes on 22 December 2026, and comes at what is a busy time for DC pension reforms. This guided retirement consultation is running alongside a consultation on draft regulations to implement Retirement Collective Pension Schemes (RCPS). RCPS is the new name for Retirement CDC – a re-brand announced in the Government’s response to its October 2025 consultation, which was published together with the draft regulations on 3 November 2026.  You can read our summary of the RCPS response and draft regulations here. There are also broader policy developments impacting the DC market, including the consultation on draft guidance on fiduciary duties of trustees in relation to investment decision-making and the newly published response from the DWP to its consultation on trusteeship and governance.

The consultation paper is detailed and technical, as therefore is this article. It covers key areas including:

  • which schemes and which members will be in scope for guided retirement;
  • the key requirements a default pension will need to meet (and factors to consider in designing them);
  • when a scheme can partner with another provider to provide their default pension;
  • the member journey through guided retirement, including the new “single point of consent” concept and member communications; and
  • governance changes – including the proposal to require trust-based schemes to put in place a pension benefits strategy.

We have also included some initial commentary on the proposals, as well as actions that trustees, scheme managers and employers can and should be taking now. An important message for providers is that whilst on the current timeline guided retirement requirements won’t come into force for the first tranche of schemes until “summer 2029”, there is a significant amount of work for schemes to do between now and then to get “guided retirement ready".

A reminder: PSA26 framework for guided retirement

The Pension Schemes Act 2026 (PSA26) introduces a legal duty for occupational DC schemes to provide “default pension benefit solutions” for DC members. 

The relevant provisions are not yet in force, but under s50, trustees or managers of occupational pension schemes providing money purchase benefits (other than those schemes excluded by regulations) will be required to “design and make available to each eligible member of the scheme, one or more default pension benefit solutions”.

A default pension benefit solution can be for the whole membership or a cohort within the membership. It must be designed to provide a regular income for eligible members in their retirement (whether or not alongside other benefits – unless a particular group of members is excluded by regulations) and there is a list of factors for trustees and scheme managers to consider when designing their default(s) including:

  • the needs and interests of the members as a whole (or an appropriate subset);
  • the circumstances of different eligible members of the scheme (e.g. their normal pension age, size of pot etc);
  • the possibility that members may already have received some of their benefits e.g. as a PCLS.

“Eligible member” means a member accruing or with an actual or prospective right to money purchase benefits.

s51 permits the scheme to partner with another arrangement to provide their default solution where either:

  1. the trustees or managers have determined that it is “not reasonably practicable for them to design and make available to the members concerned default pension benefit solutions” within the scheme; or
  2. the trustees or managers have determined that the external option will provide a better outcome for the members concerned than any solution they could provide within the scheme.

It is against the backdrop of these framework provisions in the PSA26 that the consultation paper now sets out more detail about the shape of the proposed guided retirement regime. We consider the consultation proposals below.

Which schemes are in scope?

The overarching principle is that guided retirement will apply to occupational pension schemes with members who are “primarily DC savers”. This table summarises the current proposals in relation to which types of arrangement will need to provide guided retirement.

The scope is intended to be broad, with the possibility of extending the reach to individual (i.e. non workplace) SIPPs and other non-workplace pension arrangements in future noted and views invited.

Which members are in scope?

Again, the scope of proposed member eligibility is broad:

  • Active, deferred and pension credit members will be eligible to access default pensions, as will pensioner members who have taken a PCLS / are in drawdown (on the basis they may still have decisions to make about their remaining benefits)
  • For members with hybrid benefits which include a DC benefit that is not a collective pension:
    • If the scheme is hybrid cash balance / DC, it is proposed that they should be eligible to receive a default pension in respect of their DC benefits.
    • If the scheme is hybrid DB / DC, there will only be an obligation to provide a default pension if the member has solely DC benefits.

Specific exemptions are proposed for members who would otherwise be in scope where the value of the pot is £1000 or less (i.e. is therefore in scope for automatic consolidation via the new small pots regime). It is proposed that this exemption tracks any future changes to the small pots consolidation legislation.

At the other end of the spectrum, for members with high value pots, no specific exemption is proposed but it is recognised that this is not the target cohort for the guided retirement solutions – members with high value pots are more likely to seek individual financial advice and make tailored decumulation choices. Feedback is invited on whether a specific exemption should be included, and if so at what pot size.

What are the default requirements?

As recapped above, some very broad parameters about the requirements for default pension benefit solutions were set out in the PSA26. The consultation builds on this; paragraph 3.3 provides a helpful summary of proposals in terms of the required elements of a default pension, and the factors trustees and scheme managers must consider when designing a default.

The factors in the right-hand column are the minimum required to be considered in ensuring the default pension meets the needs of the membership (or cohort of the membership) – and trustees and managers will be expected to able to demonstrate they have been considered. However, they are free to consider additional factors too where relevant. 

It is notable that RCPS is specifically listed as a standalone required factor schemes must consider. The Government has not gone as far as mandating that schemes must use RCPS as their default pension but the consultation highlights that RCPS is “being developed specifically for use as a default pension”. We know from the RCPS consultation response and draft regulations that, at least initially, RCPS will only be accessible via the guided retirement route – individual members will not be able access these arrangements on the open market. There seems to be a clear preference that, where appropriate for a particular cohort, RCPS should form part of the default pension.

There are some important proposals put forward in respect of the shape of the default pensions, particularly in respect of the requirement to consider longevity and provide a regular income. This includes: 

  • a proposed £10,000 pot size threshold below which providers would not be required to consider protection against longevity risk (recognising that providing a regular income from smaller pots may not be “practical or proportionate”). However, it is noted that although not required, providers do still have the option to offer a regular income on pots below £10,000 (and indeed should do so where this is in member best interests);
  • the £10,000 threshold would be applied net of PCLS withdrawals, and across the combined value of DC pots held by that provider;
  • defaults should be designed so that members do not have to purchase their own individual annuity;
  • providers will be expected to manage drawdown withdrawal rates in a default pension – it is considered “unlikely” that straightforward drawdown would meet the longevity protection requirements;
  • in relation to annuities, some trust-based schemes are considering bulk annuity purchase (similar to a DB buy in arrangement) as part of a “flex then fix” default arrangement – comments from contract-based providers on how this could work in the FCA-regulated market are invited;
  • innovation in developing alternative approaches that offer longevity protection is actively encouraged.

Partnering with another provider to provide a default pension

Under the PSA26 provisions, trust-based schemes can partner with another provider to deliver a default pension for their members where one of the two conditions in s51 is met (either "not reasonably practicable” to provide in scheme or external provider likely means “better outcomes”). The consultation elaborates that:

  • “not reasonably practicable” means, e.g. where it would be disproportionately costly or operationally challenging to provide in-house;
  • the “better outcomes” test could be met where another scheme offers a default pension that is “better suited to the needs and interests of the members” – RCPS is included as a specific example.

Equivalent rules will be provided by the FCA for contract-based schemes. 

A key requirement to note is that member consent is required for a transfer to another provider (this is required by s51(10) PSA26). Under the consultation proposals consent would be obtained “at the point of access”, meaning the consent to transfer would be given at the same time the member selects their pension (as part of the “single key consent moment” referred to below).

In relation to the mechanics of these transfers, views are sought as to whether a set list of what transfer agreements between schemes and partners must contain should be prescribed in regulations / FCA rules. The PSA26 gives the Government power to make regulations in a number of other key areas; the consultation confirms there is no intention at this stage to use these powers to make regulations in relation to:

  • parameters around the “not reasonably practicable” and “better outcomes” transfer conditions;
  • the timing and circumstances of transfer payments;
  • requiring specified master trusts or consolidator schemes to agree to receive a transfer (the so called “schemes of last resort” backstop power).

As announced in the October 2026 Budget, provisions will be included in the Finance Bill 2027/28 to ensure that members do not lose tax protections as a result of transferring their pension between schemes at retirement. The consultation envisages that protection will be maintained where “a member transfers all their DC pension rights from a pension scheme to another registered pension scheme to enable benefit payment and within three months of the transfer the member crystallises all their pension rights under that scheme”.

Member journey

A helpful illustrative example of a simplified member journey is included in the consultation. 

  • it is proposed that the point at which an individual requests payment from their pension will form the “single key consent moment”, at which the default pension and availability of alternatives is communicated to members;
  • it is important to understand that members will not be defaulted anywhere without their consent. If members do not consent to a default, they can choose another of the scheme’s default pensions (where the scheme has more than one) or a different arrangement altogether. A default pension cannot be put into payment without member interaction including e.g. the provision of bank details.
  • providers will be expected to “engage” individuals throughout their retirement but will not be allowed to seek consent to move the person into another phase of their default pension (e.g. from “flex” to “fix”)
  • in relation to what are termed “irreversible” elements of the default pension, such as the beginning payment of an annuity, it is proposed that providers are required to use “best endeavours” to engage the individual and give them the opportunity to update their personal circumstances / opt-out prior to that transition;
  • it is noted that FCA cancellation rights rules will also apply for individual annuities – feedback is sought on whether a period longer than the 30 day cooling off period should apply.

Under the proposed framework members will be given the option of “self-selecting” into an alternative default pension (where the scheme offers different solutions to different cohorts) or another option made available by the provider. Providers will need to make sure the range of defaults the member is told about are “appropriate” for that individual – the example given is not offering a default designed for members in ill-health to the broader membership.

The interaction with the targeted support regime is highlighted, with the aim being to provide a “seamless” service. Both targeted support and guided retirement target a similar membership demographic – those who might not pay for individual financial advice to design a bespoke retirement solution for their needs.  The consultation proposes that, where it is available, “targeted support should form part of an integrated service, so individuals have a coherent experience. Under the proposed guided retirement framework, pension providers will be required to understand the needs and interests of their members, identify cohorts, allocate individuals to appropriate default pensions and provide support based on limited information, activities which will operate in the same way as targeted support”.

In another flag of further reforms to come, the consultation notes that it “expects” further changes in the future to enable targeted support (or services akin to targeted support) to operate within trust-based schemes, and support individuals who wish to consider alternative retirement options.

Member communications

There is a whole chapter of the consultation dedicated to member communications, recognising the pivotal and challenging role member engagement and understanding will have in the success of guided retirement. 

Communications objectives for the guided retirement framework are set out in the consultation, and the proposal is that these largely are implemented via existing governance frameworks across the trust and contract-based markets. In terms of specific communications, additional requirements will be implemented through regulations and rules only where necessary to ensure there is a clear framework for the minimum level of information and support members must receive. For example, the proposals suggest there will be a requirement for schemes to adapt existing “wake up” communications for default pensions.

Again, there is a helpful example flow chart of what a member’s default pension communication journey will look like across their lifetime in the scheme.

For trust-based schemes, there will be a new requirement to provide “retirement-focused communications from five years before an individual reaches their Normal Minimum Pension Age (NMPA), with further communications at 5 year intervals thereafter until benefits are accessed”. The consultation confirms that this would be in addition to existing requirements to provide wake-up communications at four months before pension access.

The proposal envisages using NMPA based-triggers for trust-based scheme communications, to allow it to track future changes to access ages. However, it is noted that there is a divergence from the regime for contract-based schemes and Pension Wise guidance, which both use age 50 as a trigger – views are invited on whether NMPA or age 50 is preferred. Interestingly there is a proposal to require pension providers to include “factual and neutral” consolidation messaging within wake-up communications. The proposal is for such communications to include the following information:

  • “consolidating pensions could give an individual a single default pension plan which may be more straightforward to manage and understand than holding multiple pots with separate default arrangements
  • consolidating pensions is an important decision with long-term financial implications
  • not all pensions are the same, and valuable benefits or features may be lost upon consolidation
  • consumers should carefully consider the costs, charges, investment options and retirement income features of different schemes before deciding to consolidate”.

In relation to the impact of drawing a PCLS, the consultation identifies a concern that members may not always understand the impact of taking a PCLS on their future retirement income. It proposes a new requirement for pension providers to explain the potential impact of taking a PCLS, to make clear that money taken as a lump sum means a reduction in the income available in retirement. The suggestion is that illustrations or examples are included.

For the “at the point of access” communication (other than where taking only a PCLS with the rest of the member’s benefits remaining invested), members should be presented with the default pension they have been allocated to (following a period for gathering of any additional information needed to allocate the individual to their cohort and associated default). This will be the option that applies to them unless they select an alternative decumulation option. They will have the opportunity to access financial advice or targeted support where relevant.

In terms of the level of information schemes are required to provide to the member about the default, the consultation envisages a balancing act – giving members sufficient information to understand the default they have been allocated to, whilst not overwhelming them. A suggested list of aspects of the default that the provider should explain to the member is set out at paragraph 5.43. This is described as the “core information” that must be disclosed at the point of access – the consultation envisages that how the information is presented will be a matter for the individual scheme, with freedom to provide additional information where the provider considers it would support member understanding.

The interaction with existing communication requirements, in particular the “Stronger Nudge to Pension Wise Guidance” is considered. In particular, views are sought about whether requiring individuals to complete the existing Stronger Nudge process (which requires them either to take up a Pension Wise appointment or opt out) adds too much “friction” to what is intended to be a simpler journey into a default pension.

The consultation also addresses what communications should look like during retirement. For example, it is proposed that, where a member seeks to draw down more than the default pension product envisages, this would trigger a requirement for the provider to warn the member that the proposed drawdown takes them outside the default product parameters (and if they proceed the provider would be expected to reallocate them to another product – with their consent). 

Governance

The aim is to develop consistent governance outcomes across the trust and contract-based markets, whilst recognising that the frameworks for achieving these will look different for each.

Trust based schemes

  • existing fiduciary duties and governance requirements will apply and decisions about default pensions should be made within that framework;
  • under the PSA26, there will be a new requirement for trustees to “determine, review and revise” a Pension Benefits Strategy (PBS). This is described in the consultation as “a mechanism for trustees or managers to document the evidence underpinning their decisions and the rationale for them and for this to be disclosed to TPR”. TPR will be given delegated power to determine the format of the PBS;
  • the consultation proposes that alongside the PBS trustees or managers are also required to publish: 
    • evidence of how they have taken account of the design considerations for their default pension;
    • evidence about their membership and explain both how this has informed the design of their default(s) and why they consider it (them) appropriate for their membership; and 
    • where different cohorts identified within the membership, how they were identified and how their needs informed the design of the default(s).
  • it is proposed that there will be a maximum period of 6 years for the periodic strategic review of the PBS (which sits alongside ongoing monitoring requirements). The 6 year period is aligned with two 3-year review cycles of the Statement of Investment Principles, recognising the relationship between the two.
  • there will also be event-triggered reviews of the PBS required – e.g. where there is a significant change in the scheme’s membership or its investment strategy.

Contract-based schemes

  • no requirement to publish a PBS – instead “the FCA will use its well-established product governance framework to achieve corresponding outcomes, recognising that contract-based schemes are not generally required to publish their product governance records”;
  • FCA rules already prescribe “extensive requirements” for firms that manufacture products and services (including e.g. identifying a target market, designing products and services to meet the needs, characteristics and objectives of that target market);
  • for guided retirement it is proposed that these requirements should apply “both to the individual products and services that form part of the default pension and to the design and operation of the default pension as a whole”.
  • existing record-keeping requirements for product governance processes should suffice to ensure firms are able to demonstrate the rationale behind their default pension(s) as trustees can through the PBS;
  • it is envisaged that the FCA may add new rules or guidance to ensure that contract-based schemes must review their default pensions in the same circumstances as trust-based schemes (i.e. at least every six years, and in the event of one of the trigger events arising).

On a related note, there is a chapter of the consultation dedicated to compliance and enforcement. This article does not examine the proposals in detail but notes the Government intends to use its regulation-making powers to legislate to allow TPR to issue compliance notices, third party compliance notices and penalties (up to £10,000 for an individual and £100,000 in any other case).

When?

A proposed timetable for implementation of guided retirement requirements is included in the consultation. The dates included are based on the Government’s current estimates and are subject to change but give schemes and providers helpful targets to work towards.

It is envisaged that implementation will be phased, starting with master trusts and FCA-regulated schemes in “summer” 2029, with obligations for “common employer group master trusts” and single employer trusts to follow in summer 2030. The rationale is that the latter cohort are more likely to seek to offer a default pension through transferring members to another qualifying scheme and therefore it makes sense to give opportunity for the market of defaults offered by large master trusts to get up and running.

For master trusts offering RCPS as their default, there is a concession – it is proposed they will be required to comply with PBS requirements by summer 2029, but default pension requirements will not kick in until summer 2030.

For schemes that may be in the process of consolidating / winding up when the guided retirement requirements come into force, the requirements will still apply. It is proposed that those schemes use the option to partner with an external provider (presumably using the “not reasonably practicable” condition in s51) and transfer members to them in order to provide a default pension.

Commentary

  • The timing of this consultation is no coincidence, being published alongside the response to the RCPS consultation and the draft regulations for implementing those arrangements. The “nudges” towards RCPS as an appropriate default are peppered throughout the consultation.
  • Is there a risk that this solution becomes over-engineered? The aims are to be applauded but even the “simplified” example member journey looks complicated. Is there scope for greater simplification here?
  • What about benefits in other arrangements – to what extent are schemes required to design a solution that considers the individual’s other retirement savings / wider financial circumstances? This is recognised in the consultation but a substantive solution is not proposed at this point in time – there is a reference to an expectation for pension providers to “consider aspects such as individuals’ other sources of pension wealth” but no clear suggestions about how to gather that information, or evaluate it.

    This will be a key practical challenge when designing and allocating individuals to cohorts. If a member has a much larger DC pot elsewhere, a default that suggests e.g. an annuity with spouse’s pension and inflation protection from a much smaller pot is unlikely to be a desired solution. 

  • Further consolidation of pots in the pipeline? There is an interesting reference in paragraph 3.7 to the possibility of future legislation to support greater consolidation “to help savers make the most of the totality of their savings in retirement”. The consultation says that it will explore mechanisms, including “what trustees are able to do within current rules to help people consolidate pots in respect of which a default pension can then be arranged” and will engage with stakeholders on these matters “in due course”. This appears to be connected with the challenge identified above of designing appropriate defaults and allocating individuals to suitable cohorts where their pension savings are spread across multiple schemes.

    Later in the consultation, paragraph 5.27 – 5.31 considers communicating with members about consolidating their pensions and what that messaging should look like. And the consultation also notes that the Government may look to extend the value for money framework to the decumulation phase in the future – another lever by which further consolidation in the market at a scheme level may be achieved.

  • Greater protection for trustees and scheme managers? There doesn’t seem to be any suggestion that there will be any additional standalone protection for trustees and managers from e.g. complaints from members who go along with the default pension chosen for them but are later dissatisfied with their arrangements (it is noted that it is the intention that the Pensions Ombudsman (trust based schemes) and Financial Ombudsman Service (contract-based schemes) will have jurisdiction over member guided retirement complaints). Responsibility and oversight of third parties (and their products) is addressed in paragraphs 6.41 – 6.47 but the proposal is that this is all dealt with within the existing TPR / FCA governance frameworks. 

    In one sense this is understandable, most members are already in defaults during the accumulation period of their pension, and guided retirement just offers a default for decumulation (which members do not have to accept, and indeed must actively consent to). However, as the mainstream media response to the consultation launch suggests, feelings run materially higher in relation to decumulation decisions – see for example the Times’ “Stop the Pension Power Grab” campaign. This is the point at which pensions become “real” and, in many cases, the first time individuals truly engage with their pension choices. Is there an argument to say trustees and managers need some form of standalone statutory discharge, for example, where the proper processes have been complied with and a member has been reasonably allocated to a default that meets all the prescribed design requirements?

Actions for trustees and scheme managers

It is clear that there is a wealth of information schemes will need in order to design their default pensions for their membership. Many smaller and own trust arrangements are likely to be looking to partner with other providers to provide the retirement product(s) for their membership. 

Although the proposals are still at the consultation phase, the broad shape of the proposed guided retirement regime is now much clearer and there are plenty of actions for trustees and scheme managers to be taking forward now, including:

  • Identifying whether their pension arrangement is in scope – e.g. DB schemes with DC AVCs are not subject to the guided retirement requirements under current proposals;
  • Gathering the membership information needed to support the design of default pensions. Are updates to systems needed, e.g. to allow you to identify pots of £10,000 or less (the proposed threshold at which the requirement to provide longevity protection will kick in)?;
  • Working with scheme administrators to plan the communication journey for their membership – updates to key stages are going to be required (e.g. the “wake up” pack), as well as timings, given the proposed new requirement for “retirement-focused” communications to be provided from trigger dates beginning at 5 years before NMPA (trust-based schemes) / age 50 (contract-based schemes). Scripts, online journeys, data capture and processes will all need updating for the new requirements.
  • Engaging with the market to understand what partnership options there are or may be;
  • For master trusts, considering whether to offer retirement collective pensions as part of a default. If so, there is an important timing consideration to be aware of – to benefit from the 12-month extension proposed, schemes must publish the PBS stating that intention by (currently) summer 2029;
  • Reviewing scheme documentation/rules to establish whether the requisite powers are in place to enable the likely favoured default or defaults to be implemented, and associated actions;
  • Assessing the trustee board or provider’s skills, advisers and governance processes – are the right arrangements and personnel in place to meet the new requirements? This should also be considered in the context of the DWP’s recent response to its consultation on trusteeship and governance;
  • Considering guided retirement in the wider reform context – scale and consolidation requirements, value for money and the developing RCPS market all have an impact on schemes and the DC market.
  • Considering whether to respond to any aspects of the consultation – are there particular areas of the proposals that look challenging to administer in practice? The consultation closes on 22 December 2026.

Actions for employers 

  • For employers, the key action at this stage is to engage with their scheme’s trustee board or pension provider to ensure that they are aware of and planning for the new guided retirement requirements. Is there a project plan for the scheme to ensure that it will be ready to provide default pensions when the reforms come into force? And how does that fit in with their plan to address and implement the wider DC market reforms (such as the new value for money, scale and consolidation and small pots requirements)?
  • Although there is no specific employer duty in relation to guided retirement, employers will no doubt want to understand the provider’s thinking in relation to the default pension(s) they will offer (given pensions are a key employee benefit). This includes whether a scheme will be looking to partner with another provider to provide their default pension e.g. where RCPS is a favoured option, and what options are available in the market.
  • The trustees or pension provider are likely to need information from the employer to understand the scheme’s membership profile, in order to support with designing and allocating to members to appropriate cohorts. It will be helpful for employers to engage early, to understand what data is needed and ensure they have systems in place to provide it where possible. Equally employers will be keen to understand what information and reporting will be shared with them in return.

Our team of DC specialists are very well-placed to assist you with understanding all aspects of the new guided retirement duties, and planning for implementation. If you would like to discuss any aspect of this article please do get in touch with Susannah Young, Helen Woodford or your usual Burges Salmon pensions team contact.

This article was written by Louise Pettit and Helen Woodford

Related articles

01
10

See more from Burges Salmon

Want more Burges Salmon content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for content and news you can trust.

Update your preferred sources

Follow us on LinkedIn

Be sure to follow us on LinkedIn and stay up to date with all the latest from Burges Salmon.

Follow us